Bombay HC Quashes ICICI Bank Sanction to Prosecute Chanda Kochhar

The Bombay High Court has quashed the sanction ICICI Bank granted on May 15, 2023 to prosecute its former CEO Chanda Kochhar in the Videocon loan case, calling it illegal and issued by an authority that was not competent. The ruling, by Justice Milind Jadhav, rests on the process followed in granting sanction, and the court order was passed on a petition by Kochhar.

Bombay HC Quashes ICICI Bank Sanction to Prosecute Chanda Kochhar

Key takeaways

  • Bombay High Court quashed ICICI Bank's May 15, 2023 sanction to prosecute Chanda Kochhar.
  • Justice Milind Jadhav said the sanctioning authority was not competent and failed to apply its mind.
  • The case concerns a Rs 3,250 crore loan to the Videocon Group in 2012, later classified as an NPA and bank fraud.
  • Sanction is mandatory under the Prevention of Corruption Act because a bank employee is deemed a public servant.
  • The CBI had arrested Chanda and Deepak Kochhar in December 2022; both got interim bail in January 2023.

The Bombay High Court on Wednesday quashed the sanction given by ICICI Bank to prosecute its former managing director and CEO Chanda Kochhar in the case over alleged irregularities in loans to the Venugopal Dhoot-led Videocon Group. A single bench of Justice Milind Jadhav held that the authority that granted the sanction had "failed to apply its mind".

What happened

The court set aside the sanction order dated May 15, 2023. It described the order as unsustainable in law and rendered it null and void. The order came on a petition filed by Kochhar. She had argued that ICICI Bank did not follow the proper procedure when it granted sanction to prosecute her.

In its observations, the court said it was "writ large on the face of record" that the sanction was illegal and deserved to be quashed. It gave two grounds. The first was that the authority which granted the sanction was not a competent authority. The second was that the authority completely failed to apply its mind to the material, or lack of it, placed before it.

Why sanction matters in such cases

Under the Prevention of Corruption Act, a bank employee is deemed to be a public servant. Prosecuting a public servant for offences under the Act generally needs prior sanction from the competent authority. The sanction is meant as a safeguard. It requires the authority to examine the evidence independently and decide whether a prosecution is warranted.

That is why the High Court's reasoning focused on competence and application of mind. Courts have often looked closely at whether the sanctioning authority actually reviewed the material before it. This ruling concerns the validity of the sanction. The source report does not say the court gave a finding on the underlying allegations.

The Videocon loan case

The case relates to a Rs 3,250 crore loan that ICICI Bank granted to the Videocon Group in 2012, when Chanda Kochhar was heading the bank. The Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) has alleged cheating and irregularities in the way the loan was sanctioned.

According to the agency, Kochhar cleared the loan because her husband and family stood to benefit from such transactions. The CBI has alleged that, in return, her husband's company, Nu Renewable, received investment from Videocon. The loan later turned into a non-performing asset (NPA) and was classified as a case of bank fraud.

Timeline so far

  • 2012: ICICI Bank grants the Rs 3,250 crore loan to the Videocon Group.
  • December 2022: The CBI arrests Chanda Kochhar and her husband Deepak Kochhar.
  • January 2023: The couple is granted interim bail.
  • May 15, 2023: ICICI Bank grants sanction to prosecute Chanda Kochhar. This is the order now quashed.
  • June 2023: The CBI tells a special court in Mumbai that the bank had granted sanction because there appeared to be a quid pro quo in the Videocon loan.

A quid pro quo means an exchange of favours between two parties. It is central to the CBI's allegation that the loan approval was linked to benefits for the Kochhar family's business.

Why it matters for investors

For shareholders and market participants, the case has long been a reference point in discussions on governance and credit-appraisal standards in the banking sector. The source report does not mention any market reaction or any financial impact on ICICI Bank. It is also worth noting that the loan in question dates back to 2012 and has already been classified as an NPA.

The ruling deals with a procedural and legal point, namely whether the prosecution sanction was validly granted. It does not by itself record a finding on whether the loan was fraudulent. Investors tracking the matter should separate the validity of the sanction from the merits of the CBI's allegations, which the court order, as reported, does not decide.

Background: sanction and public servants

Bank officers of public and private sector lenders can be treated as public servants for the purposes of the anti-corruption law. This brings their decisions, including lending decisions, within the scope of the Act. Before a court can take cognisance of such an offence, the law requires prior approval from the authority competent to remove the person from office. In a case involving a former chief executive, identifying who that competent authority is can itself become a contested legal question.

What to watch next

  • Next steps by the CBI or the bank: The source does not say whether either will challenge the order or seek a fresh sanction. Any such move would be a key development.
  • Effect on the special court proceedings: The CBI had informed the special court in June 2023 about the sanction. How the quashing affects the trial will depend on further orders.
  • Position of Deepak Kochhar and others: The report does not detail the impact on other accused in the case.
  • Detailed order: The full judgment may clarify who the competent authority was and what material was considered.

For now, the High Court's order removes the prosecution sanction against Chanda Kochhar. The wider case over the Rs 3,250 crore Videocon loan remains part of the legal record, and further proceedings will determine how it moves ahead.

Frequently asked questions

What did the Bombay High Court decide?

It quashed ICICI Bank's May 15, 2023 sanction to prosecute former CEO Chanda Kochhar, holding that the authority was not competent and failed to apply its mind to the material before it.

Which judge passed the order?

A single bench of Justice Milind Jadhav passed the order on a petition filed by Chanda Kochhar.

Why is sanction needed to prosecute a bank official?

Under the Prevention of Corruption Act, a bank employee is deemed a public servant, and prosecution requires a valid sanction from the competent authority.

What is the Videocon loan case about?

It concerns a Rs 3,250 crore loan ICICI Bank gave the Videocon Group in 2012. The CBI alleges cheating and irregularities, and says Videocon invested in Nu Renewable, a company of Deepak Kochhar. The loan later became an NPA and was classified as bank fraud.

Does the ruling decide whether the loan was fraudulent?

As reported, the ruling addresses the validity of the prosecution sanction, not the merits of the CBI's allegations.

Own a stock in this story? Check it for red flags in seconds. Open the checker →

This article is for information only and is not investment advice.