How the red-flag score works
A transparent, rule-based screen. Every check, threshold and weight is listed below.
The scoring in one minute
- Each check is marked Green, Amber or Red using the thresholds below.
- Green earns the check's full weight, amber earns half, red earns nothing. The score is points earned ÷ points possible × 100, using only the checks with data.
- Critical flags — auditor resignation, qualified audit opinion, SEBI/exchange orders and ASM/GSM surveillance — cap the score at 49.
- Verdict: Safe = score 75+ with no red flags · Risky = score below 50 or 3+ red flags · otherwise Caution. At least 4 checks are needed for a score.
The checks
| Check | Amber at | Red at | Weight |
|---|---|---|---|
| Promoter shares pledged High pledging means promoters have borrowed against their shares. A price fall can trigger forced selling by lenders. |
≥ 10 % of promoter holding | ≥ 25 % of promoter holding | 12 |
| Change in promoter holding (last 4 quarters) Steady promoter selling can signal that insiders see limited upside or need cash. |
≤ -2 percentage points | ≤ -5 percentage points | 8 |
| Auditor resigned mid-term (last 3 years) critical Auditors rarely quit early without reason. A mid-term resignation is one of the strongest governance warnings. |
— | Yes | 12 |
| Qualified / adverse audit opinion critical A qualified opinion means the auditor could not fully verify the accounts. |
— | Yes | 10 |
| Related-party transactions Large dealings with promoter-linked entities can be used to move money out of the listed company. |
≥ 5 % of revenue | ≥ 10 % of revenue | 7 |
| SEBI / exchange order or penalty (last 3 years) critical Regulatory orders around disclosures, insider trading or fund diversion are serious red flags. |
— | Yes | 10 |
| Debt to equity Too much debt makes a company fragile when interest rates rise or business slows. (Not applied to banks/NBFCs.) |
≥ 1 x | ≥ 2 x | 9 |
| Interest coverage ratio Shows how many times operating profit covers interest cost. Below 1.5x the company may struggle to service debt. |
≤ 3 x | ≤ 1.5 x | 8 |
| Contingent liabilities Off-balance-sheet claims and guarantees that could become real liabilities. |
≥ 25 % of net worth | ≥ 50 % of net worth | 5 |
| Cash from operations ÷ net profit (3-yr) Profits that never turn into cash can point to aggressive accounting or stuck receivables. |
≤ 0.8 x | ≤ 0.5 x | 9 |
| Rise in debtor days (3-yr) Customers taking much longer to pay can mean sales are being booked too early. |
≥ 20 days | ≥ 45 days | 4 |
| Repeated equity dilution (last 3 years) Frequent fresh issues, warrants or QIPs reduce existing shareholders' stake. |
— | Yes | 3 |
| Credit rating downgrade (last 12 months) Rating agencies downgrade when they see rising risk of default. |
— | Yes | 5 |
| Under ASM / GSM surveillance critical Exchanges put stocks under surveillance for unusual price/volume moves or weak fundamentals. |
— | Yes | 6 |
Data sources
Checks are based on public disclosures: exchange shareholding patterns and pledge filings, annual reports and auditor's reports, credit-rating agency releases, SEBI and exchange orders, and NSE/BSE surveillance lists. Each stock page shows when it was last reviewed.
Limitations
A screen can't capture everything. Banks and NBFCs carry high leverage by design, so debt ratios are less meaningful for them. A clean score is not a reason to buy, and a red flag doesn't always mean fraud — use it as a starting point for your own research.